Can AI Practice Law in Brazil? What the OAB v. Enter Lawsuit Tests

Last reviewed: October 22, 2026.

No. In Brazil, representing a party in court and giving legal advice are activities reserved by statute to lawyers admitted to the Brazilian Bar (OAB). An AI tool can help a lawyer research, organise and draft, but it cannot take the lawyer’s place: acts reserved to lawyers that are performed by someone who is not admitted are void, and the lawyer who signs a filing remains liable for it. In October 2026, that line reached the courts for the first time in a high-profile case, when the São Paulo section of the OAB sued the legal AI company Enter.

What Brazilian law reserves to lawyers

The rules are in the Brazilian Bar Statute (Law 8.906/1994). Article 1 lists two activities that only admitted lawyers may perform:

  • Litigation: filing claims and petitions before any court, including small claims courts (Article 1, I).
  • Legal advice: legal consulting, advisory services and legal management (Article 1, II).

The second item matters most for AI. Brazilian law does not only protect the act of signing and filing a document. It also reserves legal analysis and advice to lawyers. A tool that drafts text for a lawyer to review raises few questions. A tool that decides the strategy of a case and delivers that advice directly to the client is much closer to the activity the statute reserves.

Three other provisions complete the picture:

  • Nullity: acts reserved to lawyers that are performed by a person not admitted to the OAB are void, without prejudice to civil, criminal and administrative penalties (Article 4).
  • Liability: a lawyer is liable for acts performed in professional practice with intent or negligence (Article 32). Signing an AI-drafted filing with a fabricated precedent does not shift that liability to the software.
  • Criminal exposure: practising a profession without meeting the legal requirements may, in principle, be a misdemeanour under Article 47 of the Misdemeanours Act (Decree-Law 3.688/1941).

There are narrow exceptions in which a party may appear without a lawyer, such as small claims up to 20 minimum wages (Law 9.099/1995, Article 9) and habeas corpus (Law 8.906/1994, Article 1, §1). These exceptions let the party speak for itself. In my reading, they do not authorise a company or platform to give legal advice to that party, because legal advice remains reserved under Article 1, II.

The OAB v. Enter case

On October 7, 2026, the São Paulo section of the OAB filed a public civil action (ação civil pública, a collective lawsuit that bar associations and other entities can bring to protect diffuse interests) against Talisman AI Ltda., which operates as Enter. The case was assigned to the 4th Federal Civil Court of São Paulo under number 5031169-20.2026.4.03.6100.

Enter provides AI tools to the in-house legal departments of large companies that handle high volumes of civil and labour litigation. According to the complaint, as reported by the Brazilian legal press, the platform reads case files, organises procedural information, suggests litigation strategy and drafts defences at scale. The São Paulo bar argues that these are activities reserved to lawyers and must be under the effective supervision of an identified, responsible lawyer.

The action does not seek to shut the company down. Among other measures, the bar asks the court to:

  • preserve evidence on how the system works;
  • suspend advertising that presents the product as a substitute for lawyers;
  • restrict new contracts for the challenged features until the responsible lawyer is identified and reviews are recorded;
  • require verifiable, auditable human supervision, logs of strategies and changes to filings, and the lawyer’s right to reject AI output;
  • order an independent audit;
  • award R$ 1 million in collective moral damages to the federal Diffuse Rights Fund.

Enter disputes the allegations. The company says it has been in dialogue with the Federal Council of the OAB, that many of the requested measures are already part of its operations, and that the lawyers hired by its clients remain responsible for reviewing, signing and filing every document. It also says it does not use client data to train AI models. These are the company’s own statements and have not been tested in court. The preliminary requests have since received a first, partial answer, described in the next section.

What the court has decided so far

According to Migalhas, on October 21, 2026 the judge in charge of the case, Raquel Fernandez Perrini, granted a partial preliminary injunction. It orders Enter to preserve its records from January 1, 2024 onward, with a fine of R$50,000 for each violation. As reported, the court did not order the platform suspended and did not bar new contracts, which were among the bar’s requests.

The same report says the court refused to stay the case while the company talks with the Federal Council of the OAB, and gave the Federal Council 10 days to report. The merits of the case, meaning whether Enter’s features amount to practising law, are still undecided. A preservation order of this kind protects the evidence for a later decision. It says nothing yet about who is right.

Migalhas also reports that the Rio de Janeiro section of the OAB asked to join the case as a co-plaintiff, and that the court admitted it. We have seen the admission reported in only that one source. Check the case docket before relying on it.

The bigger picture: a national guideline

The lawsuit did not come out of nowhere. On August 17, 2026, the plenary of the Federal Council of the OAB unanimously approved a proposal by its president, Beto Simonetti, authorising legal action against AI companies that intermediate between clients and lawyers or that, while selling AI tools, perform activities reserved to lawyers. Under the guideline, the bar’s leadership reviews concrete cases and decides whether to sue. The Enter case is the first high-profile lawsuit in this new phase.

Other steps by the bar

The lawsuit sits on top of a series of institutional steps. These come from press reports, and we have not read the primary texts of the most recent ones:

  • November 11, 2024: the Federal Council approved a recommendation on the use of generative AI in legal practice. It is a recommendation and carries no sanctions.
  • April 16, 2026: the São Paulo section’s ethics tribunal (TED) issued an opinion on the subject.
  • June 10, 2026: the OAB presented a national plan on artificial intelligence.
  • October 13, 2026: OAB Resolution 16/2026 was published. Migalhas reports that it sets rules for conduct-adjustment agreements (known as TACs) with legal AI vendors. If that description is right, it offers vendors a negotiated route alongside litigation. We have not read the resolution itself.

A separate point avoids a common confusion. CNJ Resolution 615/2025 regulates the use of AI inside the judiciary. It does not set rules for lawyers’ own use of AI tools, so it should not be read as the standard that governs the Enter dispute.

Where the line falls in practice

  • AI can support: legal research, document review, summarising case files, tracking deadlines and producing first drafts for a lawyer.
  • A lawyer must still: decide the strategy, verify every statute and precedent cited, give advice on the client’s concrete case, and sign and file.
  • The practical test: who answers for the result? If an admitted lawyer reviewed and signed it, the AI is a tool. If no one answers for it, the AI is occupying a space the law reserves to lawyers.

What this means for foreign legaltech and AI vendors

For companies selling legal AI in Brazil, or planning to, the case points to a few practical precautions. These are my suggestions, not requirements set by a court:

  1. Position the product as a tool for lawyers, not a replacement. Marketing that suggests clients no longer need a lawyer is itself one of the targets of the São Paulo complaint.
  2. Make human review provable: keep records of who reviewed each AI-assisted document and when.
  3. Let the lawyer say no: the responsible professional must be able to reject AI output without breaking the workflow.
  4. Put data commitments in the contract: retention, training use and segregation of client data should be written terms, not website claims, especially under Brazil’s data protection law (LGPD).
  5. Work with Brazilian counsel before offering features that analyse cases or recommend strategy to end users who are not lawyers.

For the wider legal map, see our Brazil Guides.

A checklist for law firms and legal departments

Whatever the final outcome in São Paulo, the complaint shows what the bar is looking at. Law firms and in-house teams that buy legal AI can use the same points as a due-diligence list. These are my suggestions, not requirements set by a court:

  • Can you name the lawyer who is responsible for each output that leaves the tool, and is that review recorded?
  • Does the vendor keep logs of suggested strategies and of changes made to filings, so that a supervising lawyer can show what was reviewed?
  • Can your lawyers reject or edit the AI output without the system treating it as final?
  • Does the vendor’s marketing claim that the product replaces lawyers? If so, expect the same criticism the São Paulo complaint makes.
  • What does the contract say about retention of records and about the use of your data to train models? A preservation order like the one in the Enter case can reach a vendor’s records.
  • Is every statute and precedent cited in a draft verified by a person before filing?

Related guide: Tech & data in Brazil.

Read more in Portuguese


This article is for informational purposes only. It does not constitute legal, tax or investment advice, does not create an attorney-client relationship, and is not a solicitation of clients. See our Disclaimer.

Sources


About the author

Luiz Guedes is a Brazilian attorney (OAB/PB 11.005) based in João Pessoa, with more than 25 years of experience in corporate, tax and labor law and a doctorate in Economic Law from the Federal University of Paraíba (UFPB). He writes LawGeek International to explain Brazilian law and regulation to foreign investors, founders and builders in tech and crypto.

Academic profile (Lattes) · About LawGeek · Contact

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Scroll to Top